Focused Staffing Group
Resources
Leadership guide

The Personnel File Checklist for Joint Commission and CARF Surveys

By Robert Flom · Updated November 18, 2026

The short answer

A survey-ready personnel file, direct hire or agency-supplied, shows a license or certification verified at the primary source, background checks, exclusion screening, a job description, the health records your state requires, orientation and training records, a competency assessment and a performance review. Joint Commission recorded moderate to high risk credentialing and competency findings in 193 of 1,380 behavioral health surveys, 2019 to early 2020.

Get the audit checklist

Key takeaways

  • Joint Commission recorded moderate to high risk credentialing and competency findings in 193 of 1,380 full behavioral health surveys (14%) from January 2019 through March 2020.
  • Joint Commission applies every Human Resources Management standard to contracted professionals, and CARF defines personnel "regardless of employment status" and requires documented reviews of all contract personnel.
  • A photocopy of a license is not primary source verification: the record needs the date, who verified, what was verified and the result, at hire and again at renewal.
  • HHS OIG updates its exclusion list monthly, and the provider carries the overpayment if an excluded person from a staffing agency furnishes billed services, so ask for the agency's screening record and keep it.
  • Focused Behavioral completes every compliance file before a candidate is shortlisted, and VerifAI runs 4 AI checks on every document and tracks each expiration date.

What do Joint Commission and CARF look for in personnel files?

Both look for the same proof: that each person delivering care is qualified, verified, oriented, trained, assessed as competent and reviewed, and that your records show it. Neither makes an exception for a professional an agency supplied.

Joint Commission surveys behavioral health programs under the Human Resources Management (HRM) chapter of its manual. Surveyors arrive unannounced or on short notice for most surveys, and the competence assessment session runs 30 to 60 minutes. The surveyor picks whose files to pull from the tracers just walked, then checks your stated process against what those files hold (source: Joint Commission, Survey Activity Guide 2026).

In full surveys from January 2019 through March 2020, Joint Commission recorded moderate to high risk findings on credentialing and competency assessment in 193 of 1,380 behavioral health surveys, or 14%. Its published surveyor notes describe license verification that was late or missing at hire, renewal or expiry, an initial competency assessment with no documentation 6 months after hire, and competency evaluations that did not match the job description (source: Joint Commission, Heads Up: Credentialing and Competency Assessments).

CARF posts a workbook openly: the 2026 Standards Workbook for Unaccredited Participating Providers, in effect July 1, 2026 through June 30, 2027, which CARF describes as a subset of its ASPIRE to Excellence standards. In that workbook the workforce standards are numbered 17 through 20.

What is checkedJoint Commission, behavioral healthCARF
Who is coveredEvery HRM standard applies to contracted professionals who provide care, treatment or services, as it does to direct hires, volunteers and students.Personnel are the workers who deliver, oversee and support the program, "regardless of employment status."
License and certificationHRM.01.02.01: primary source verification at hire and at renewal. The record shows the date, who verified, what was verified and the result. A photocopy of the license does not meet it.Written procedures to verify licensure, certification, registration and education with primary sources, in every state where the person delivers services. Copies handed over by the person do not meet it.
Background and healthHealth screenings and criminal background checks completed as law, regulation and your policy require.Criminal checks, immunizations, fingerprinting, drug testing, vulnerable population checks and driving records where required, before services begin and throughout employment.
Orientation and trainingHRM.01.03.01: orientation, documented, covering your policies and procedures, key safety content and specific job duties.Orientation, on-the-job training and documented training on the competencies each role needs. Health and safety training at orientation and at least annually.
CompetenceHRM.01.06.01: an initial competence assessment, documented, then reassessment once every 3 years or more often where your policy or the law requires (2021 public sampler). The initial assessment was one of the 5 behavioral health requirements most often found noncompliant in 2023.A process that keeps services consistent with licensure, certification and the training that maintains established competency levels.
Job description and reviewHRM.01.01.01: written job descriptions.Current written job descriptions, performance appraisals for personnel you employ directly, and documented reviews of all contract personnel.

(source: Joint Commission, Standards Sampler, and Standards FAQs on primary source verification (archived January 2026) and contracted staff; CARF, 2026 Standards Workbook) Standard numbers and the 3-year interval are as printed in the public sampler. Read them against your current manual.

What belongs in the file for a direct hire and for an agency-supplied professional?

The same 8 elements belong in both files. What changes is who gathers each document. For an agency-supplied professional the agency usually holds the source documents. You hold proof that each requirement was met, plus the parts only your program can do: orientation, the competency assessment and the review. With an agency that finishes the file before it presents anyone, 4 of the 8 arrive complete and dated.

File elementDirect hireAgency-supplied professional: who usually holds itWhat you must still be able to produce
License or certification, verified at the primary sourceYou verify with the state board or the BACB registry at hire and at every renewal.The agency verifies before it presents the candidate.A dated verification record: who checked, what was checked, the result. Run the lookup yourself and keep it.
Background checks and clearancesYou request each check your state requires for the setting.The agency obtains them before the start date.Proof that each required check was completed, with its date. Where your state says a copy is kept, the copy.
Exclusion screeningYou search the OIG exclusion list before hire and every month after.The agency screens, under a written term in your agreement.The agency's screening documentation, requested and kept.
Competency assessmentYou assess the person against the job description and document it.The agency holds its skills screen. The assessment for your setting is yours.A documented assessment for the duties this person performs in your program.
Orientation and training recordsYou deliver and record them.The agency holds prior training certificates. Orientation to your program is yours.A dated orientation record and a training record for the person.
Health requirements, where your state sets themYou collect the physical examination and TB test your licensing rule names.The agency collects them.Confirmation that each one is complete and current.
Performance reviewYou complete the appraisal on your cycle.You, from what your supervisors see on shift.A documented review of the contracted professional.
Job descriptionYou write it and keep it current.You write it for the assignment. The agency recruits to it.The description, and evidence the person meets its minimum qualifications.

Joint Commission draws one useful line: you are not required to share the actual results of a health screening or a criminal background check, only that each was completed (source: Joint Commission, Standards FAQ on contract staff, Behavioral Health, archived June 2025). State licensing rules can ask for more.

Competency is assessed where the work happens. Joint Commission says competency assessment centers on what your population, your procedures and your equipment demand, and that skills intrinsic to a person's professional education generally need no separate assessment (source: Joint Commission, Standards FAQ, Competency Assessment vs Orientation, archived February 2026). A BCBA arrives knowing how to write a behavior plan. Your crisis procedures and your documentation system are assessed on site.

Which state and federal rules does a personnel file audit rest on?

Your state licensing regulation, your state background check law, the federal exclusion rules and, for ABA, the BACB. Both accreditors tie their requirements to law and regulation, so these rules set the day counts a file is read against.

RuleWhat it puts in the fileThe clock
Pennsylvania 55 Pa. Code § 6400.21, community homesA State Police criminal history check for people hired into direct contact roles, part-time and temporary included. An FBI check when the person lives outside Pennsylvania. A copy of the final reports.Applied for within 5 working days after hire. Completed no more than 1 year before the hire date.
Pennsylvania 55 Pa. Code §§ 6400.50 to 6400.52Orientation in 5 areas, annual training, and a training record for each person showing source, content, dates and length.Orientation before working alone and within 30 days after hire. Each year, 24 hours for direct service workers and 12 hours for consultants and contractors who work alone with individuals. Licensed, certified or registered contractors who serve fewer than 30 days in 12 months are exempt from both.
Pennsylvania 55 Pa. Code § 6400.151A signed and dated physical examination that includes a TB test.Within 12 months before starting, then every 2 years.
Pennsylvania child abuse history clearanceClearances for people who work with children.Renewed at least every 60 months.
Virginia 12VAC35-105-400 to 480Background check documentation, a written job description, a documented process for verifying professional credentials, and a personnel record. The rules name contractors alongside direct hires.Orientation within 15 business days. Performance evaluated at least annually. The record kept 3 years after the person leaves.
Ohio Adm. Code 5123-2-02, developmental disabilitiesChecks of 7 databases before hire, among them the OIG exclusion list and the state abuser registry, and a criminal records check.Database checks repeated at least every 5 years.
BACB, RBT HandbookSupervision documentation for each RBT: dates, duration, format, observations and supervisor names.Kept at least 7 years. A lapsed RBT has 30 days to reinstate and may not practice or bill while inactive.

(source: Pennsylvania Code, § 6400.21, 6400.50, 6400.51, 6400.52, 6400.151; Pennsylvania DHS, child abuse history clearance; Virginia Administrative Code, 12VAC35-105-400, 410, 420, 430, 440, 480; Ohio Administrative Code, rule 5123-2-02; BACB, RBT Handbook)

Exclusion screening sits under all of it. Anyone on the HHS Office of Inspector General's List of Excluded Individuals/Entities (LEIE) can receive no payment from federal health care programs for what they furnish, and a provider that hires someone on the list may face civil monetary penalties (source: HHS OIG, Exclusions Program). OIG updates the list monthly and says screening each month best limits overpayment and penalty exposure (source: HHS OIG, Special Advisory Bulletin, May 8, 2013).

What must you be able to show for agency-supplied professionals?

Everything you would show for a direct hire. You stay accountable for the file, whoever recruited the person and whoever holds the paperwork.

Joint Commission applies every HRM standard to contracted professionals, states that contracting with another accredited organization does not by itself assure compliance, and requires you to monitor contracted services against defined performance expectations under LD.04.03.09. Its 2026 survey guide lists the competency assessment process for contracted professionals as a session topic. CARF requires documented reviews of all contract personnel. Virginia's background check statute reaches any person under contract to serve in a direct care position (source: Code of Virginia, § 37.2-416).

OIG is the most direct. If an excluded person supplied by a staffing agency furnishes services billed to a federal program, the provider carries the overpayment. Relying on the agency's screening can reduce your penalty exposure when the agency agreed to it by contract and you confirm it is happening, for example by requesting and keeping the screening documentation. The overpayment stays with you whoever screened (source: HHS OIG, Special Advisory Bulletin).

What to require from any agency in writing

  • Qualified people only. The agency supplies only professionals who meet the minimum qualifications and competencies in your job description. Joint Commission names this as the term a well-written contract carries.
  • Primary source verification before the start date. Each license and certification is verified with the board or registry, with the date, the verifier and the result recorded, and verified again at each renewal.
  • Every check your state requires, done first. Background checks, clearances and the health records your state sets are complete before the first shift, each with its date, and stay current for the whole assignment.
  • Exclusion screening every month. The agency searches the LEIE before placement and each month of the assignment, and sends you the record.
  • Notice of any change. The agency tells you in writing when a credential is about to expire, lapses or is disciplined.
  • Same-day access. Surveys come unannounced. Any document in the agency's file reaches you the day you ask.

How do you audit an agency's credential packet in 10 minutes?

Check 8 things in order, starting with the ones you can confirm yourself at the source. A packet that fails one goes back to the agency before the first shift.

  1. Match the name. The name on every document matches the person's government ID.
  2. Verify the credential yourself. Look up the license on the state board's site. For a BCBA or RBT, search the BACB Certificant Registry, which shows certification status, published disciplinary actions and, for an RBT, the supervisor on record. Save the dated result (source: BACB, Certificant Registry).
  3. Read every expiration date. License, certification, clearances, physical and TB test: none expired, and none due to expire during the assignment.
  4. Count the background checks. Each check your state names is present and inside its window.
  5. Confirm exclusion screening. The agency's LEIE search is dated this month, or you run the search yourself and save it.
  6. Confirm the health documents. Each one your licensing rule sets is complete and current.
  7. Hold it against your job description. Education, experience and credential meet the minimum qualifications for the role.
  8. Schedule what is yours. Orientation before the person works alone, the competency assessment and, for an RBT, your BCBA adding the technician as a supervisee in the BACB account. With no supervisor on record, the registry lists the RBT as inactive and the RBT may not practice (source: BACB, RBT Handbook).

How do you keep licenses, clearances and training from lapsing between surveys?

Put every dated item for every person in one tracker, direct hires and agency-supplied professionals together, and work it on a calendar.

  • Track the date, not the document. License, certification, each clearance, physical and TB test, annual training hours, competency assessment and performance review each get a due date and an owner.
  • Verify again at renewal. Joint Commission expects primary source verification at renewal as well as at hire. Look the renewed license up again and file the new dated record.
  • Screen exclusions monthly. Run the LEIE for everyone delivering billed services, and collect the agency's record for anyone it supplied.
  • Sample files every quarter. Joint Commission's own self-check for behavioral health programs suggests reviewing a sample of HR records quarterly.

This is the work VerifAI does for every professional we place. VerifAI is our AI-powered credentialing platform. It reads every license, certification and clearance on upload, checks it, and tracks it to its expiration date. Four AI checks run on every document: expiry, signature, name and authenticity. Our credentialing team approves each document, and only approved documents appear on a candidate presentation. The platform carries the expiration date of every approved document and starts renewal reminders before it lapses, so your office is not the one following up. See how VerifAI tracks credentials.

What does Focused Behavioral do to keep your files survey-ready?

We finish the file before you meet the person. Every compliance file, including background clearances, licensure verification and required documentation, is completed before a candidate is shortlisted to you, not after an offer is extended.

Each candidate presentation lists every approved document and clearance with the date it was approved, so the proof a surveyor asks for arrives with the candidate. Our credentialing system flags expirations before they lapse and keeps every file audit-ready. That is how we target 2 to 4 weeks from candidate identification to start-ready, against an industry norm of 6 to 8 weeks. The credentialing timeline guide shows where those weeks go, and the vacancy cost guide shows what each one costs.

Every BCBA candidate goes through a structured clinical interview with Nicole, our Director of Operations and a practicing BCBA. We work with 1 client per region, so the professionals we recruit for you are never offered to the provider across town. Focused Behavioral staffs BCBAs, RBTs and DSPs nationwide for providers like Keystone Human Services and Merakey, with 12 years of staffing experience behind every search, across group homes, residential programs and IDD services.

Send us the role and your file requirements

Tell us the role you need filled and what your state and your accreditor require in the file. You get candidates whose documents are already approved, listed and dated. If you would rather walk through your requirements first, book a 30-minute call.

Free download

Take the checklist to your files.

36 lines in 6 parts, from the job description to agency-supplied professionals, each one a thing a surveyor can ask to see, with a place to list what is missing and who closes it.

  • A PDF to print: 1 copy per personnel file
  • An Excel workbook that audits 8 files side by side and counts the open lines in each
  • Pennsylvania and Virginia rules noted where they set a date or an interval

Get the audit checklist

Tell us who you are and both files are yours right away: the PDF to print and the Excel workbook to edit.

FAQ

Questions, answered.

What does a Joint Commission surveyor look for in a personnel file?

Proof that the person is qualified and that your process works: a license or certification verified at the primary source at hire and at renewal, completed background checks and health screenings, documented orientation, a competency assessment and a job description. In surveys from January 2019 through March 2020, Joint Commission recorded moderate to high risk credentialing and competency findings in 193 of 1,380 behavioral health surveys.

Does CARF require primary source verification of credentials?

Yes. CARF's 2026 Standards Workbook for Unaccredited Participating Providers calls for written procedures to verify licensure, certification, registration and education with primary sources, in every state where the person delivers services. Confirmation comes from the board, the school or a credentials verification organization. Copies supplied by the person do not meet it. High school diplomas are exempt. College degrees required for the position are verified.

How does Joint Commission staffing compliance work for professionals supplied by an agency?

Yes. Joint Commission's public FAQ for behavioral health says every standard in the Human Resources Management chapter applies to contracted professionals who provide care, treatment or services, and that a surveyor may ask to review their files. You need not share the actual results of health screenings or background checks, only show that each was completed. Contracted services are also monitored under LD.04.03.09.

Who is responsible for exclusion screening when an agency supplies the professional?

The provider. HHS OIG says a provider carries the overpayment when an excluded person from a staffing agency furnishes services billed to a federal health care program. Relying on the agency's screening can reduce your penalty exposure if the agency agreed to it by contract and you confirm it is done, for example by requesting and keeping the screening documentation, but the overpayment stays with you. OIG updates its exclusion list monthly.

How do you verify a BCBA or RBT certification?

Search the BACB Certificant Registry. A newly certified RBT appears within about 24 hours of passing the examination, and the registry shows certification status and the RBT's supervisor on record. An RBT with no supervisor on record is listed as inactive and may not practice. The BACB also issues a written verification letter for $25. Save the dated result in the file.

How often does a competency assessment have to be documented?

Joint Commission requires an initial competence assessment, documented, for each new person; it was one of the 5 behavioral health requirements most often found noncompliant in 2023. Its 2021 public Standards Sampler then sets reassessment once every 3 years, or more often where your policy or the law requires. State rules add their own clocks. Pennsylvania community homes owe 24 hours of annual training for direct service workers, and Virginia requires performance to be evaluated at least annually for direct hires and contractors alike.

What does Focused Behavioral send with each candidate?

A candidate presentation that lists every approved document and clearance with the date it was approved. Every compliance file, including background clearances, licensure verification and required documentation, is completed before a candidate is shortlisted. VerifAI, our credentialing platform, runs 4 AI checks on every document, our credentialing team approves each one, and every expiration date is tracked from then on.

More guides for provider leaders.

What an open BCBA, RBT or DSP seat costs

Put a dollar figure on one open seat with your own hours and rates, and see what four weeks sooner is worth.

Read the guide →

How to staff a new ABA clinic

The 60-day plan: the BCBA first, then RBTs, with the license, clearance and payer clocks that decide your opening date.

Read the guide →

Direct Hire, Temp-to-Hire or Contract: Which Fits Your Program?

Compare direct hire, temp-to-hire and contract staffing for BCBAs, RBTs and DSPs: cost timing, speed, risk and the conversion terms to get in writing.

Read the guide →

Covering Residential and Group Home Shifts Without Living on Overtime

How group homes and residential programs cover DSP and technician shifts without mandatory overtime: the FLSA math, state ratio rules and a 30-day forecast.

Read the guide →

Recruiting BCBAs When Every Provider Is Hiring

How to recruit BCBAs when postings outnumber them: what BCBAs weigh in an offer, a term-by-term offer table, state license rules and a 7-day hiring plan.

Read the guide →

Reducing RBT and DSP Turnover Without Breaking the Payroll Budget

How to reduce RBT and DSP turnover without an across-the-board raise: exit-survey reasons, caseload standards by role, coverage, and a free audit worksheet.

Read the guide →

How Long Credentialing Takes for Behavioral Health Staff — and Why It's Usually 6–8 Weeks

How long behavioral health credentialing takes, clearance by clearance in PA, NJ, MD and NY, where the weeks go, and a tracker to cut it to 2 to 4 weeks.

Read the guide →

BCBA, RBT and DSP Pay Benchmarks by State

DSP, RBT, behavior technician and BCBA pay by state from NCI, BLS and state Medicaid rate studies, with dates, sources and how to use them in hiring.

Read the guide →

Have an open seat right now?

Tell us the role and the location. We tell you who we have and how fast they can start.

Free 30-minute call · No cost · No obligation